Go to Jeff Salisbury LWGate Home Page.From: Roger Tawa <rogerta@videotron.ca>
Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom
Date: Sat, 03 May 2003 10:02:19 -0400
Next Article (by Author): [CANSLIM] Accessing the discussion canslim archives... owner-canslim@xmission.com (Jeff Salisbury)
Previous Article (by Author): RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Top of Thread: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Articles sorted by: [Date]
[Author]
[Subject]
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. - --Boundary_(ID_CpRBuA9uCl+Pf/AeLYzXDQ) Content-type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1 Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT Hi all, I just noticed the date on this ask bill o'neil question. Is this yet one more coincidence that something we talk about here makes into investors.com just a few days later... :-) ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] -----Original Message----- From: owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com [mailto:owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 11:26 PM To: canslim@lists.xmission.com Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Hi Roger, This may shed some additional light on the subject: ==== Ask Bill O'Neil Friday, May 2, 2003 "When checking for distribution days in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, do you use the market volume or the DJIA volume?" To analyze the Dow, IBD uses the NYSE Composite volume rather than the Dow's volume. The idea is that when looking at a market index you want to examine market volume. It's for this same reason that IBD uses NYSE volume to gauge the S&P 500, which is made up mostly of NYSE stocks. The S&P 500 and Dow charts on investors.com also use NYSE volume. ===== --Katherine -----Original Message----- From: owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com [mailto:owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 8:06 PM To: canslim@lists.xmission.com Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Hi all, Fyi, here is email thread with Bill: -----Original Message----- From: WmGraLee@aol.com [mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 9:02 AM To: Roger Tawa Subject: Re: Market Tester question (fr-ws) I think you could be right -- it might explain why backtesting shows better results for the NAS. In a message dated 4/30/2003 9:13:39 AM Central Standard Time, Roger Tawa writes: Subj: RE: Market Tester question (fr-ws) Date: 4/30/2003 9:13:39 AM Central Standard Time From: Roger <mailto:rogerta@softimage.com> Tawa To: WmGraLee@aol.com <mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com> Sent from the Internet Hi Bill, Yes, I have confirmed this with csi. Here is my email conversation with them. Could this explain why you feel the market tester works best with the NASDAQ market than other markets? Thanks. -----Original Message----- From: WmGraLee@aol.com [mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 30, 2003 8:47 AM To: Roger Tawa Subject: Re: Market Tester question (fr-ws) HI Roger -- You raise some good points. Who did you talk to at csi? Also, do you or csi know of any data services that do report Dow, S&P 500 etc volume? Bill In a message dated 4/29/2003 8:18:26 PM Central Standard Time, Roger Tawa writes: Subj: Market Tester question (fr-ws) Date: 4/29/2003 8:18:26 PM Central Standard Time From: Roger <mailto:rogerta@videotron.ca> Tawa To: order@market-tester.com <mailto:order@market-tester.com> File: winmail.dat (3984 bytes) DL Time (26400 bps): <1 minute Sent from the Internet Hi Bill, I found out about your market tester from the canslim@lists.xmission.com <mailto:canslim@lists.xmission.com> email list. I have a question about your data source. On your methodology page, you say that the market tester uses msn, and hence csi data, as a data source. However, are you aware that csi data does not calculate volume for indices? For example, both the S&P500 and Dow Jones Industrial indices report the total NYSE volume, not the volume of the indices themselves. I have confirmed this with csi. The NASDAQ composite index however seems to report the total NASDAQ volume, which is probably ok, but this part I have not confirmed. What effect do you think this has on your market tester when used with indices besides the NASDAQ composite? This does not seem to be in the spirit of WON's definitions of distribution day or follow through day. Looking forward to your response, thanks. ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] <snip> - --Boundary_(ID_CpRBuA9uCl+Pf/AeLYzXDQ) Content-type: application/ms-tnef; name=winmail.dat Content-transfer-encoding: base64 Content-disposition: attachment; filename=winmail.dat eJ8+IhMOAQaQCAAEAAAAAAABAAEAAQeQBgAIAAAA5AQAAAAAAADoAAEIgAcAGAAAAElQTS5NaWNy b3NvZnQgTWFpbC5Ob3RlADEIAQ2ABAACAAAAAgACAAEGgAMADgAAANMHBQADAAoAAgAAAAYA9AAB A5AGAKAXAAAnAAAACwACAAEAAAALACMAAAAAAAMAJgAAAAAACwApAAAAAAADAC4AAAAAAAMANgAA AAAAHgBwAAEAAAAOAAAAbWFya2V0IGJvdHRvbQAAAAIBcQABAAAAOQAAAAHDDS7OLcFYDRGaW0TY lzSaOjclpK8AFgzFgAAU3n4gAB47KRAAF/4VIACZFU/gAAL1GFAAFiQMQAAAAAIBHQwBAAAAGgAA AFNNVFA6Uk9HRVJUQUBWSURFT1RST04uQ0EAAAALAAEOAAAAAEAABg4A/NSQfBHDAQIBCg4BAAAA GAAAAAAAAADYgkB07BfyR7qjdFWfyrp8woAAAAsAHw4BAAAAAgEJEAEAAADLEgAAxxIAAC4yAABM WkZ1YJEWuwMACgByY3BnMTI1cjIMYGMxAzABBwtgbpEOEDAzMw8WZmUPkk8B9wKkA2MCAGNoCsBz hGV0AtFwcnEyAACSKgqhbm8SUCAwAdCFAdA2D6AwNTA0FCHzAdAUEDR9B20CgwBQA9T7Ef8TC2IT 4RRQE7IY9BTQXwcTAoMOUARVFr0xEvw3/RQBOROjFHIUUBTQCFUHsv0V5DQC4xa3GlEXfhQwIS+k fVcLgGdkImFzGgR+OBZPH/8YZxQUGNIU0WGeaANxAoMPsRGdMjMjQcUkgiAHbSBDRSckHvFPJ70U QCjPKdV5cickNrkRjjE2FjEsHwOCRwnRamsnJDcuDzYf5S+fVO8IcCckI0EuLTcxUTK/A4KQKEhl YglwdyknJPo5NK83KL821gcQAaAN4Hc3tBRQOD84LfE5jwOCQv0HQHQN4DtUFj8omAcTKia+NBpR P10r10DVLXU0HvHPI3wvCEDUMKg0NURvMnf7QNQ0BjQt8USNNbdA1DdL/jQxUUnuQFw63CNPPMhA 1P8+ajghGo0olg6QHekqJhQw/1J/K8ZUDS11DkEafi8GVAx9MKg1J4FYrx/kVAw0BjXfHvFb3jW1 VAw3SzVHEV7v91OvYQI66jUt8VvePNVUDP8+aQ4wTK8omSbTKiYOME+f9yvJaoUtdTIT8E+vLxhq hP8wqG4QPy8yaWqENAZuEEG//zWpaoQ3S24QJ4FM33UdOup/bhBEXzzJaoQ+ZgKRCOY71QlvMH1P ZQ4wNX56f5H/f0+AWX5kgIJ+74K/gn2B//+AL35/EGAjMIhKiWGJH4op/35kilKIv4yPjE2Lz4n/ jcT+OQ5QkRSScYqTknCNxFuRPQnDNQBQipMToAKCc3RUeWwHkGgJ4HQAAHF5AyFsaQFABRABQAPw ZNhjdGwKsQBgcwqwlzAjI/CXcm51bQIAYWGIdXRvAGBkanWVYPEFEGdodJaRCgGWYAoB8mkBkHAw AzFxEgwBD1efEBgI0AnAlvCbM25wm4nDnSQDMHNuZXgkQAewzwWwAMACcxMQY3MPkAMw15jwIpA+ kHYTgEQBEJigaT6AIFAKwGEJwJpwaDwgRgIhlSOT8JYTZml6LQ+QOJniouOWrDdwZN5yCVCkgiOw pIJ3RwE3cP+XkAHQn+GXn5ivmbai45pf95tvnH+djmKmQAmAAiCpgc+ec5PwoQCZsXQtoaADYQo6 PVBvr0BTdWJqBQWQdK9ARGF0ZTr/ofQt8KJ/o4+kn6Wvpr+nz/+o3JWwtkAiYQ4hqYEMMKm0Pw5Q qj+rT6xfrW+ud1Jl+6BgJBEgN1C2QASQofQxUP+xD7Ifsy+0P7VOCGCXIAuA9mWVkKBgbAFAtk+3 X7hkyyExCNBiCrB0OLj4qhZ+Mh7wEBbKQbr0E1AkgG/8b2a7T7xfvWfJEL6AC1D8eS+hsMLgCxG+ 9SLTn7D/a3C/78D/wg/DH7VPxh+o3/+p77p/zD/NT85fz2KvYq8E/7A5OCCWL5c/1S+ZX9d0yMN+ Ode/2M/Z39rvvVjj8ETcb2PhMAnwBUBN14CfRufUI6AW5BdjZuPx59afwn/gcL6xAiBBAZVQfWDO 4SB2RQDAAxBTlXIB0JUjMv8AUN8P4B/hL+I/13/k3+Xv7+b/vRvu4O3ALe3iBgDyUHXtEHQIcGV8 cxMQfWB2QQJRIHtVbmsTUHd9FdF978L6wPAA0tEBgG6/r8AAYAnwoBDpEMtxeAtgqQJAb3kJ8Fye kHCVsP8AIAuQE1Cg0dLQ8IAA4QIwcwJgAIBiZAwwE1EKsGM/ARAFsKDQAgGfALhCZVxJJuByevxy ZGf4sHJ2ZwuBAVBo/4M8wA8BZ/52AhkA0fJQ1vEcwJSQAqG5A5U5OB7wAeIm4HcEI/8FVK/Q/YAN sAsw/HGVcOzApQ5QdgiQd2vi8GQe8PkHUnNj8KAQYFVRDgDSou+VwPHgCLUQ0G/ygPCAzvD+dPrQ xWH7wgpH8nD4sPGg//CAy3H+8PJw8eH+0Q5gE3D/PoC88P7w8GD+8P7RB6HvQO8KUAhB8AD+4HcO E/7R/cDnjlDvQPvwcmv/8eryJDE7EvKwUG3tkLBBoIA6XOpcrpBvoVFtoaDuAJWgPRGQTXlQLiDs 8PvQIE/+ZtDQ/7ARkBNG9HP9YPiy+i69MHT7EBxg8ADPgPLi756QVWAVU6CkY/pRG/L/APGv4Gx2 bJSQ8SESwPFQvxdR40D9wBfSB6HpUTfrcd/xICPw9FCiEPEgdJ6gasD+LvmkF1YHMBfy/jEYXxlv /Rp/bFug8SC/MP6QHD8dT38eX1ag8SAOgBv/IL8hxCnfGrxHEB+PJG8hpGJ48Ghh/yWPF4Mt8CM/ J/8pDyofF7D/MVArYhg/LM8t3xq8a3Arb/8w7zH/Mw8XsN7gL+81fzaP/zeUCWDPYQlgyeDi8O8w 7x//8C/xP/JP81/0b/V/9ot8oRHrZkhpID7AbCwNSgo8YiBGlUkgQCIgJ/9gaCF9cCB0CSAgZB8R Mr1ASFFugEZAc2sgz07wRmBI4IhQcXUJ8BFQP56A+NFKMJWgaCC9QC4g/0dgSVBJI/0woPB8kutm vUB/EVBb0H1gTEt8wOLwTatpv0xaOhH/sExLSGCwQCDs8GfpQEkhQnAgdxFQ40Bsd0mQeTDFISAJ IE1x+LBr9ZWgIK6xb1PRoGCVYAOQ/HMufMASEEeTasDKsF4AzUigeUlQESJyhUxLaHHpB2BsZBcS ZleQ4vBHsQBTWU1CT0wgN8Y0PVAAICAiV7iBuHL8cyJZAUlQn8BoYleQbwD/fDDrEXny63B8gExa RpxoYj9XclfifXBBYFe6RXkgQQBVVE9URVhUTOhJU1RaAyL4nlnwfII/WqVFYuuwyd/K4suFID3v ZQ9mH2cMRpVSEdDP4GphB89QRpVAkHRwOi8vf+NAz1D/sOlgoTAU4J6AdPIvRpVbT00hUfRS1D5R 27hhAWBzr0AAcGkTEW7gpnDswP8ALl1rBlcJIJ09AHnFIFGgP9BwLG7i9idNcb0xZW4HPFQ9Hz4v /z8/QE/jJTxPcX9yj3OfdK//QZ9Cr0O/RM9cOnDcOlJ3X/94b3l/eoQ6UuM0YuL4cBcSkGJrbWs5 YyBf6ZDz7gCwMWF9TEPrIWNPZFlaLYmiTwOj7SFNlaBz/aFAZYmjf8t2Vr+v0WDRIP/Rr9K/08/E L8U/1h+Nwsef/8ivyb/Kz8vffnuFsa8EENDfUtCHZUjg+tDP4C0IQP8AOXcQbUB3EFhAVLB4bW1J QHNLMlTSW/iyg3A6+5v/nQ1df7yMGNB/jc+O3/+P75D/ku+T/nt/fI+Y/5oH95Ywh69kHVPpURGA m0itj/9kSprQq2BV0G9w6ZDtsJfQD29w63CqQFpAMToyNv2+AE1c+K0/sR/dka+vtU+/ZKSe751n s/+3v665dfwATxVhtt+8T2SVUkWbEFvQQ0FOU2BgTaCAAXH/U6DpcFLg/QG693YPgP+CD/+m74Qv qR+qL6s/ma/4cH/P/8PvxPPGRcd/VzLjEOtRl/HvhbFGIWiDRo1USTL4sO2w/wBwSDFRskZA6pPt A3cQeiH7SOQRUHO91UacZ9ldYhuQFYWiQUmBQknCTydO/0qhRpWyKrMQswVGnFlQbrL6YwkgYweR UjD/0UiQufH9egBixnBLMVW0dpFIYukA7VWgSk0RSVBJ/FDG4+0h/kHq4GqAaKBvcOggbuMM8fdI U8GlBGBs6TFI4F1A3mPISklB4dU/ItIdVBBzBoDFcHl64RTeoW9wSRxCRODiS6IRUE5ZU+hFIENU 4HAS4MgwEVC/4eVqgEhh4mIGgN5WJ0lQ/+HkS2DS8BFQypAJMFPQS6L1UYF3brJsmLDcg1GBVWD7 waU58nhu42kAOjBIUFQQn/gwEgCSUeFsS2BJdOkR/9zSSSOKsOeyCTAS8EkCUYHv5bfmg+HlVAFn xmBooEhT0FMmUCAIkDBvcOrQvRPwaOpC+LAAoODgcE1B/1hADjBI4Fkw5oNUcdxwVLD/6bPzBeSR FZDeotxAOYFJUL9I8VQ8xXAS8ODj8XkuXPnv0NlnykaViyBL5/OSUVyN/3DroqPOP89KoqPQR9EG 16T7NDCWgDErQL7PiL+Jz4rfk3EHonI0NHqSMjXOD/8h0Ahzzx0I44UmljEC/wQP/7HGmvoMbw1/ ZJWej50Pnh//Ew+gPQwvEK+urw9vGH+xT+GyXyA4OjCzvhs/HE//tk8gPyFPuO8V7x+PI98k7/+9 ryhvKX/AT8FfuvYHH/7vN///AQ+FoTdGH9lkeWn3b3BTM0lBZWEj6FDwIQfQ/8Sg6FDYg9YdK9WF ogV/BocfeqJNgyhUmpc5uSBXbYJHaoBMZWVAYeHw+xQrPk5dPA+asK9TPYodz9WzMjkfIDJf0E1A 75qwf7axPYpoiETvQfG91UZLZTebENowL5NU+CFosXF1E/gh3aIoZhUwd3Mp//qcNSBc+DTzTSzu 4GuzUrD7bvK60HVdwMIA58HU44sg/1PQWFDtsNTy7YB2ZOrQ02D6Ymowa+dAS2Fr8ZTwFPD/N0BQ MGmgaLHwINWgYrDvJvHmYUFTLkekR6TfQOvCDwZk3dHnQAfQNC8zMMIvRCUxMzozXGBEwL/mwGpU KvDIQPbgcQJUJmD/4FFoiOrAegBSgb4wVSlHp89M6zE8V8DERHNilWGMgL5h0RCjj6SayAGlgjZg 4v+kYGMARKAzL13ihSq9wpsQ/7t2LoNKX0trm3ZHpIcRSiH/Vw9YH1kmR6Sa1LtxT/B/cXtEoFnE PBSFmKBZ4chAQL3T0GbdkBSAVnCgQj6bhf9HWbaxa6k+T2y2cJ5uhken/mlBx9zAmuHhI1XQZdGS YH9lgGcrdn++hGlQNUHYkizfdg/ioHfmdf93yFnfEOWRrTbQYZKgT8FuonBy0/D3B9DvgzgzYycw 7tA1MDb1/m3TYDdkfQHgAQaA3ZM4M/3hMW1+cebQT/Lvg1GK4LLfl6CSsOEqUoJZ8Xf4UPXQj1Ah hmCAd1TCREFRg3fP6GIv8OgSL3RzP27x6GH/9dF6r1uJOe86/0evPR8+L38/P0BPQV+Nq9Og3wHZ 40HvmJA3kWhwHqc0NSBEz0Xf/0bvR/9JD0ofZg+IT3nxewveSE8QWcSMBpgUWeDB5+D3NzDVgdPi Z+swB9DnADOwfxNxjkFTEN0BB9DgsshAbN9PcO1R6qF+QYehQfjh4Gfz3OF+QSBrBPDewAVBLODP 02BWoeow8TBydvOw5hP/6qHggTcA5wD3gOVU9lZTcD5j4wadzdiSVR9WLjI5+2iUHxAxHxCzo2mf WV9ab/+wT+3CZA2az2ZPZ1+sT61f/2qPa59sr6ZA9EAv8A8AJ2GeYW6Pb574UPRAckAvdL4tg/Rx W74/v0RzLEbYoNeakbJXxKBuFIIuVqG8NtIoaUA4NC/QeVKBtLB8REyug0uwtvAIkMhwYvZwTBAP MDyNMO2x3YC4lX90D3UfnM+d+3h1qkvcwXX/9uHgwOuxL+DNceCxhxaD5n/IlyYfE9eYFGy2z88T 1z7/mmA3ZNLCfnF8leows8fNo7+YFM4DpcTOEaZgfnFPqxDfzgRTcFMQ4IDrIGeCkF+A/+BC4LJe wIKQ6oODT5gU8SP4bXNuHiD20urhpmCks3+lwtxB3yDqMNcKnfv3IGX/f+HcQTcB7MKvYTcB6oPd Bt+m4fFBBPCjQfjQY0/waAHv52ZUUuxhplI/uKVUYe2Cv1GgrsEv4YVE9lH2mkp9ENvxQasAZPEg u7BpBiHjpf+nFoDRmBQzcKKx8WoeIOISf8ji8cUFQcji5+aA0vEwbP/4EdS3mBR9D34X9hKFpSeB /6FgJzDiwefh5MA20N+EpgH/7JGi8qck6QWDUellhbTqFj9SAKZQOGA3MR1hUkBibPmCkG9r5THN cX2jX4GzMD98leIR7a3eq6Hw4QFlZv8EgCtQpBZPNH2j1QDdsLQh/84PhEHcoduyOBSYFOfmhMH/ u3HsU+/fh6M3MeHH8dKi8n9QMVHR6NdhIO5AUPEFQVf4T04nALH5oDOwC8C0Ef/7UR2g6ADncvYR tBJDUaSC/1RQNYClITfBT+BQgAWC3qv6TB2Aa1LCVFHgkYGBpDN/U7OhYNJgrsGGgogRqko9PwtP DF8NTJ10l35QkHRweDovL2NQr3CmYLdzLvXJcS+ddFvX4ODCUsLNpL9fgTgAivDcELIwUwBpbdC5 fKFwcMhQJtCQ9Vuh8Nf88dmDM3Bw2WMnNwHYsP/m8BQWFm+JaUylXH8xvzLP/zPfTN8dUSzPKkoN TyFPIk3/MEWu+DBFD78QxDBFEY8Sn78TpyZGFK8VuU09MEU83CAsaXC8JsfAKrJwa207sxDccV9D oMvgZ/FhfQkZBn0AL9AAHgBCEAEAAAAzAAAAPEVQRUFJTkRERk9OS0lDTUhMQ0FFRUVBS0NNQUEu a21hbG1AZWFydGhsaW5rLm5ldD4AAAsAAYAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAAOFAAAAAAAAAwAD gAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAEIUAAAAAAAADAAeACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAABShQAA J2oBAB4ACYAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAFSFAAABAAAABAAAADkuMAAeAAqACCAGAAAAAADA AAAAAAAARgAAAAA2hQAAAQAAAAEAAAAAAAAAHgALgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAN4UAAAEA AAABAAAAAAAAAB4ADIAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAADiFAAABAAAAAQAAAAAAAAALAA2ACCAG AAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAACChQAAAQAAAAsAOoAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAA6FAAAAAAAA AwA8gAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAEYUAAAAAAAADAD2ACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAAY hQAAAAAAAAsAUoAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAAaFAAAAAAAAAwBTgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAA AEYAAAAAAYUAAAAAAAACAfgPAQAAABAAAADYgkB07BfyR7qjdFWfyrp8AgH6DwEAAAAQAAAA2IJA dOwX8ke6o3RVn8q6fAIB+w8BAAAAnwAAAAAAAAA4obsQBeUQGqG7CAArKlbCAABQU1RQUlguRExM AAAAAAAAAABOSVRB+b+4AQCqADfZbgAAAEM6XERvY3VtZW50cyBhbmQgU2V0dGluZ3NcQWRtaW5p c3RyYXRvclxMb2NhbCBTZXR0aW5nc1xBcHBsaWNhdGlvbiBEYXRhXE1pY3Jvc29mdFxPdXRsb29r XG91dGxvb2sucHN0AAADAP4PBQAAAAMADTT9NwAAAgF/AAEAAAA0AAAAPFBDRUhMS0tES01OSE5Q TE9GR0dMS0VETUNGQUEucm9nZXJ0YUB2aWRlb3Ryb24uY2E+AAMABhBvd8usAwAHEEMNAAADABAQ AAAAAAMAERABAAAAHgAIEAEAAABlAAAASElBTEwsSUpVU1ROT1RJQ0VEVEhFREFURU9OVEhJU0FT S0JJTExPTkVJTFFVRVNUSU9OSVNUSElTWUVUT05FTU9SRUNPSU5DSURFTkNFVEhBVFNPTUVUSElO R1dFVEFMS0FCTwAAAADQwA== - --Boundary_(ID_CpRBuA9uCl+Pf/AeLYzXDQ)-- - - - -To subscribe/unsubscribe, email "majordomo@xmission.com" - -In the email body, write "subscribe canslim" or - -"unsubscribe canslim". Do not use quotes in your email.
Next Article (by Author): [CANSLIM] Accessing the discussion canslim archives... owner-canslim@xmission.com (Jeff Salisbury)
Previous Article (by Author): RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Top of Thread: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Articles sorted by: [Date]
[Author]
[Subject]