Go to Jeff Salisbury LWGate Home Page.From: Roger Tawa <rogerta@videotron.ca>
Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom
Date: Sat, 03 May 2003 09:54:59 -0400
Next Article (by Subject): RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Previous Article (by Subject): Re: [CANSLIM] market bottom "Gene Ricci"
Next in Thread: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Articles sorted by: [Date]
[Author]
[Subject]
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. - --Boundary_(ID_EvbxkvU4Cg+ItJWPakaZcA) Content-type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1 Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT Hi Katherine, Thanks for the info. This seems to imply that the market tester is doing the right thing. ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] -----Original Message----- From: owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com [mailto:owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 11:26 PM To: canslim@lists.xmission.com Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Hi Roger, This may shed some additional light on the subject: ==== Ask Bill O'Neil Friday, May 2, 2003 "When checking for distribution days in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, do you use the market volume or the DJIA volume?" To analyze the Dow, IBD uses the NYSE Composite volume rather than the Dow's volume. The idea is that when looking at a market index you want to examine market volume. It's for this same reason that IBD uses NYSE volume to gauge the S&P 500, which is made up mostly of NYSE stocks. The S&P 500 and Dow charts on investors.com also use NYSE volume. ===== --Katherine -----Original Message----- From: owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com [mailto:owner-canslim@lists.xmission.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 8:06 PM To: canslim@lists.xmission.com Subject: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Hi all, Fyi, here is email thread with Bill: -----Original Message----- From: WmGraLee@aol.com [mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 9:02 AM To: Roger Tawa Subject: Re: Market Tester question (fr-ws) I think you could be right -- it might explain why backtesting shows better results for the NAS. In a message dated 4/30/2003 9:13:39 AM Central Standard Time, Roger Tawa writes: Subj: RE: Market Tester question (fr-ws) Date: 4/30/2003 9:13:39 AM Central Standard Time From: Roger <mailto:rogerta@softimage.com> Tawa To: WmGraLee@aol.com <mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com> Sent from the Internet Hi Bill, Yes, I have confirmed this with csi. Here is my email conversation with them. Could this explain why you feel the market tester works best with the NASDAQ market than other markets? Thanks. -----Original Message----- From: WmGraLee@aol.com [mailto:WmGraLee@aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 30, 2003 8:47 AM To: Roger Tawa Subject: Re: Market Tester question (fr-ws) HI Roger -- You raise some good points. Who did you talk to at csi? Also, do you or csi know of any data services that do report Dow, S&P 500 etc volume? Bill In a message dated 4/29/2003 8:18:26 PM Central Standard Time, Roger Tawa writes: Subj: Market Tester question (fr-ws) Date: 4/29/2003 8:18:26 PM Central Standard Time From: Roger <mailto:rogerta@videotron.ca> Tawa To: order@market-tester.com <mailto:order@market-tester.com> File: winmail.dat (3984 bytes) DL Time (26400 bps): <1 minute Sent from the Internet Hi Bill, I found out about your market tester from the canslim@lists.xmission.com <mailto:canslim@lists.xmission.com> email list. I have a question about your data source. On your methodology page, you say that the market tester uses msn, and hence csi data, as a data source. However, are you aware that csi data does not calculate volume for indices? For example, both the S&P500 and Dow Jones Industrial indices report the total NYSE volume, not the volume of the indices themselves. I have confirmed this with csi. The NASDAQ composite index however seems to report the total NASDAQ volume, which is probably ok, but this part I have not confirmed. What effect do you think this has on your market tester when used with indices besides the NASDAQ composite? This does not seem to be in the spirit of WON's definitions of distribution day or follow through day. Looking forward to your response, thanks. ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] ================================================= Roger Tawa http://tawacentral.net/ [One thing about paradigms: shift happens.] [When you stop, you're done.] <snip> - --Boundary_(ID_EvbxkvU4Cg+ItJWPakaZcA) Content-type: application/ms-tnef; name=winmail.dat Content-transfer-encoding: base64 Content-disposition: attachment; filename=winmail.dat eJ8+IjsNAQaQCAAEAAAAAAABAAEAAQeQBgAIAAAA5AQAAAAAAADoAAEIgAcAGAAAAElQTS5NaWNy b3NvZnQgTWFpbC5Ob3RlADEIAQ2ABAACAAAAAgACAAEGgAMADgAAANMHBQADAAkANgAAAAYAJwEB A5AGAPwWAAAnAAAACwACAAEAAAALACMAAAAAAAMAJgAAAAAACwApAAAAAAADAC4AAAAAAAMANgAA AAAAHgBwAAEAAAAOAAAAbWFya2V0IGJvdHRvbQAAAAIBcQABAAAAOQAAAAHDDS7OLcFYDRGaW0TY lzSaOjclpK8AFgzFgAAU3n4gAB47KRAAF/4VIACZFU/gAAL1GFAAFfRf4AAAAAIBHQwBAAAAGgAA AFNNVFA6Uk9HRVJUQUBWSURFT1RST04uQ0EAAAALAAEOAAAAAEAABg4AzLpyexHDAQIBCg4BAAAA GAAAAAAAAADYgkB07BfyR7qjdFWfyrp8woAAAAsAHw4BAAAAAgEJEAEAAAAnEgAAIxIAABAxAABM WkZ1SUsqzgMACgByY3BnMTI1cjIMYGMxAzABBwtgbpEOEDAzMw8WZmUPkk8B9wKkA2MCAGNoCsBz hGV0AtFwcnEyAACSKgqhbm8SUCAwAdCFAdA2D6AwNTA0FCHzAdAUEDR9B20CgwBQA9T7Ef8TC2IT 4RRQE7IY9BTQXwcTAoMOUARVFr0xEvw3/RQBOROjFHIUUBTQCFUHsv0aBDgWTxdfGGcUFBjSFNEs YWgDcRoEORGOMjOLHvEgMiAHbSBDRQKDnxQQI08UQCR/JYV5ciYEcxpREawxNhYxJ88Dgkf9CdFr JgQPwCnPGlErDwOCnlQIcCYEJ5Ep3Tc3Lk8hJYQoSGViCXB3KfUmBDUwXzckbzKGBxABoOsN4DNl NjPvODdhNT8DgvpCB0B0DeAmBDFxHywkSP8HEyXXHv8neDyFKSUUUB8O9yq4PIQsWDQWPy4YPIQv tr40GlFAPTFnPIQy+zQtAfdFnjwMNos0J5FAPTiHPIT9Ohk0M9EajSRGDpAd6SXW/jQ3YU5OJ4VP vT+GPWEajf8qtk+8QhkjMVRfLjRPvC+23xQwV28xVk+8Mvs1QsFan/9PX1yyNpoOQV3vOIVPvDoZ /w4wSF8kSSKDJdYOMEtPJ3n/ZjUpJQ4wN2FAP2W8LFgOMP863y4ZZjQvtg4wPW8xWWY0vzL7DjAj MUiPcM02mjIT8L9yrziIZjQ6FgKRCOY7CW/qMHj/ZQ4wNXoqe0F6//98CXoUfDJ6n35vfi19r3vf /3ovEGAe4IP6hRGEz4XZehR/hgKEb4g/h/2Hf4WviXQ5/w5QjMSOIYZDjiCJdGRhCcMPXbGGQxOg AoJzdHlsVQeQaAngdAAAcQMhbB5pAUAFEAFAA/BkY3T2bAqxAGBzCrCS4B+gkyIIbnVtAgBhYXV0 Ym8AYGRqdZEQBRBnvGh0kkEKAZIQCgFpAZD8cDADMULCDAEPVxAYCNDnCcCSoJbjbnCXOZjUAzDw c25leB/wB7AFsADAcwJzExBjcw+QAzCUoGTplgBpdhOARAEQlFA6MDQgUArAYQnAliBoIB5GAiGQ 04+gkcNmaS09D5A4lZKek5JcMyBkcu8JUKAyH2CgMndOATMgk0D/AdCbkZNPlF+VZp6Tlg+XH/uY L5k+YqHwCYACIKUxmiNnj6CcsJVhdC2dUANhOoU5AG+q8FN1YmoFkIJ0qvBEYXRlOp2k/zdgni+f P6BPoV+ib6N/pIz/kWCx8AuADhKlMQwwpWQOUJ+l76b/qA+pH6onUmWcEP0fwSAzALHwBJCdpDFw rL9/rc+u36/vsP4IYJLQC4Ble5FAnBBsAUCx/7MPtBQwy8QwCNBiCrB0OLSopcZ+MieQEBbF8bak E1AgMG/8b2a2/7gPuRfEwLowC1C8eS+dYL6QCxG6pXOdpP9vgLufvK+9v77PsP/Bz6SP/6Wfti/H 78j/yg/LEqsSqrT/q+kjMJHfku/Q35UP0yTEc34502/Uf9WP1p+5CN+gRNxvY9zgCfAFQE3TMJr2 58/Tm8bfx2Nm36Hjhptyf9wgumECIDyxkQB5EMqRIHZFAMADEFORIgHQkNMy/wBQ2r/bz9zf3e/T L+CP4Z/v4q+4y+qQ6XAt6ZIGAO4AdejAdAhwZXgjExB5EHZBAlEge1VuaxNQd30V0X3rcvZw67DO gQGAbr+rcABgCfCbwOTAxyF4C2CpAkBveQnwXJpAcJFg/wAgC5ATUJyBzoDsMADhAjBzAmAAgGJk DDATUQqwYz8BEAWwnIACAZqws/JlXEkikHJ6+CJkZwDAcnZnC4H9AGj7MzhwAUFn/nb9yfyB7gDS oRzAkED+Ubn/RTk4J5D9kiKQd//T/wEEq4D5MA2wCzD4IZEg6HClDlB2CJB3awuAZCeQ/wMCBPAH QBBgWlEOAM5SkXB37ZAEZRDQb+4w7DDKoHT/9oDBEfdyBffuIPRg7VDsMP/HIfqg7iDtkfqBDGAT cDow/7ig+qANoPqg+oEDUerwBgD3A/HrsPqQdwnD+oH5cIoA8+rw96Bya/uh5qIf4RLyHawAbelA q/GcMDpcXPWqQG+dAW2dUOmwkVANQB5NdQARoOig94AgT2Z/zID7YA1ADvbwI/kQ9GIu/bjgdPbA E3DrsMsw7pKaQPf+8BEDnFRj9gEb8vqwq5D4bHZskEDs0Q5w7QATAd8IIPlwE4IDUeUBN+ch7NBv H6DwAJ3A7NB0mlBmcC7/9VQTBgLgE6L54RQPFR8WL/5sLQDs0Lrg/OAX7xj/Gg+/J5Ds0AowF68c bx10KRZs7zPQGz8gHx1UYnSgZBEhP/8TMzdgHu8jryS/Jc8TYDFw/ycSE+8ofymPFmxvgCcfLJ// La8uvxNgcpArnzEvMj8zRP8FEMsRBRDFkN6g6uDqz+vf/+zv7f/vD/Af8S/yO3hR5xZwSGkgS6vw kXA8cWWoLA0KOBIgQqVUHQGoa3Mg+4EgQiEg3qC/BYAWUEEpRXBDgGowILqA/wygQ9A7gERgDLHp YEIgq/D7RCP9IWuRkEQgkVCsAF/g/0XBuOC0MUQjPBNEIbQxRLvXQqxkEgMQbD+AZkvgeSA/PRAS wkwR3qCREEEaIEEAVVRPVEVYVEyYSVNUOQCd0CAi9E7+IktwZBJL4FUAnJF4Uedg58WPxpLHNSA9 Uy9UP1Us/UKlUg2AWWF0QMsAQqU8QOB0cDovLwggywD7YE/lEGBgEJCaMHQvQqVbtk+aMEl0IHTg wNEgOgHbtBH9EHOq8PwgaQ7BapCmcOhw+rAuXVkmV5FwnTiwecDQReA7gHAsXQL+J3kQSHGaMFwn OAQ4zznf/zrvO//e1Tf/X59gr2G/Ys//PU8+Xz9vQH9KWl78NgJlf/9mj2efaKQ2At7kUQL0IBLC mGJrbUPANSIgX+VA8+mwq+FhfUtyc8FRX1JqWi13wk//U+jRTZFQc/2c8GV3w23rZHa7X80QzND/ zV/Ob89/v9/A79HPe+LDT//EX8Vvxn/Hj2ybc9GqtAyA21pAdYUg9nHLkC0D8PqwOWUwbUBlME0Q XBB4bclFwHNpuPAuY9mgWYDb9GJxkDqKH4stXW3cejj/zC9773z/fg9/H4EPgh5pn79qr4cfiCeE UHXPUj1T5QE/DTCJaJuvUmqqsJmAYXl/XZDlQOlghfBdkOcgmGAgoDExOjI2qjBNSxj/m1+fP9lB nc+jb1LEjQ+Lh/eiH6XfnNl197AREaT/qm8JUrVSRYkwW0NBTvpTToBNjqBHdVpQ+LGpF/9kL28f cC+VD3JPlz+YT5lf/4fP9CBt77IPsxO0ZbWfErH+Zv7w5wGGEXPRQdFWo0Kf/0XB9GDpYPwgTEBF 4NmgDQC/5jTos2UwSULXkEQjc6v1H0KsVflLghdAc8JBc2sMIELpsGUATydOZb/psEKloEqhMKEl QqwiXMP6Y1zQYwNBSMBD8uZQaAL+YrSQqLFIcKCAQ9BksUQyseSwdyBKXjFD0En4APu1A+jRQeaQ WsBWwF2Q14DvXQMIoUcqABBs5OGKAEQUkERKSUHP9T8iQq3nRmACMAQAeXrPNMzBXZA4SUJEzwJG MURBTlnQU0UgQ9mgcA6Q3uC/DQDQBVrAQiJG0sxnJ0PQ/dAELkNxRFH8UDfARcFG4/p3XNJshtDK o0cBN8BHdf01onhdA1cg5RFGUeRQDbDngHHPjNfASXTXMUP0RcL/DbBJAQTg6KFG1NPX1KPQBR1G UWe0gFbARCNTJlC6IARAMF2Q2PAPoGhIQvf0YPxQzwBwR2AOkLMA6WD/UvHUo11RypBcENfT4SXS sf8RQMzCymA1MUPQw1Fo4IDAf11RULCL0wQA6KDPA9+ZLv9LGb75VepCpXlAQgdKrV8L/5DDvF+9 apDDvme/JsXEL+D9hKAxJvCs73bfd+94/18nyZCSNDRosjI1vC8dgP/2k7099wNzRoRR8R/yL5/m /4ka+o/7n1K1jK+LL4w/AS//jl36T/7PnM/9jwafn2+gf/AgODowod4JXwpvpG//Dl8Pb6cPBA8N rxH/Ew+rz/8Wjxefrm+vf6kW9T/tD+4fW+8vc8E3QcKzkGzALUb8eWldkEIxRFFD0EYQT1L/1nDe QfXwssDWcMajxD0Z9f9zwvOf9KdowtDAFkeItyfZUCBXbUdawExGAEDuYdAQAkssbl0qL4jQnXNX K6oL76FSOQ1AMk3wTf8vD4jQpNErqlaoMw8wEav1XTRrZYkwyFAds1RH9HEmdUfxy8IoZgNQd3P+ Kei8I0BLGCMTO0zNUElz98aQXRKo8HVL4LAgSQZ5QP9EYHTA29DDEtqwZITY8OMQ+mJYUGtH4kii gxADEEPQfz5QV8BW0d5Aw8BQ0EPYTvhBUy41xDXEzWDZ4vSEB8vx1WD18DQvMzAv4TJFMTM6M03Q MuDU4N9YdBkQtmDlAF8iVBSAznH/VqjY4GggQKGsUENJNcc7C2cfXEXgsmRzYoOBeqBh3/BQka+S urYhk6I2TwKSgP9RIDLAIU9MAnNKq+KJMKmW/xyjOH85i4mWNcR1MThBRS//Rj9HRjXEiPSpkT4Q bZEywL1H5DwCpYbASAG2YEDnEN5mwoACoOCwAkI+iaU1eX+k0VnJLG9a1l6+XKY1x2n/L+fdUIkB z0ND8FPxgIB0wL9VS2SfrKRXcL+hxrIsZC/v0MBmBmQfZehZzTDTsSTw1mGAwD3hbpCQcsIQ9fB7 3aMmU2MVUNfAv5AlFW3/4xAlhGshziH0oMuzJlPPUf5tbJHU8D4S3aM/qs7ShcDvgJDPSkCiSBF3 5nDj8D5Bx3SAbpdC4kRBUXGX1oLnsEDWMh2Ucz9dEdaB4/H/aM9JqSgPKR81zys/LE8tX78uby9/ e8vBwM0hMXNBhrD3JbFWkAzHNCNAMu8z/zUPfzYfNy84P1Qvdm9oEWkrSO89MEfkeiaGNFnO4c5A 2HD7w6HCAmfZUPXw1SAh0AGRv3xhQTDLIfXwztK2YGzGkO/bcdjBbGF1wUHnAc6HywH5bGEga/MQ zOALsRsA4xDnRMHYUN9Qcnbh0NQz2MF/zqElINUg5aDTdOR2z9Bjn9Emi+3GskM/RE4yOVa0/Q0w MQ0wocNXv0d/SI+eb//b4lItiO9Ub1V/mm+bf1ivf1m/Ws+UYOJgsED9IBWBYU9cr12+5nDiYHJA HZQt33IUX3usX61kYUxGxsCIsWugd7LAbgKiLkTBqlYoaVdgODQd8HlAoaLQRD5MnKM50KUQ+HC2 kGJw+zow/VA8e1Db0cugprViL79jP4rvjBtmlZhr3VF15QH/PcDZ0R4Au5HO0XU2cga2t78UPwH3 hjRa1r3vAfc+yID/JYTA4myRarXYUKHnu8OGNN+8I5PkvDGUgGyRT5kwvCTvz9BBMM6g2UBn4xBN oM5if87STODjENijcW+GNN9DbfxzbgxA5PLZAZSAktOT4r/KYc1A2FDFKowb5UBlbgH/ymElIdri nYElIdijyyaVAe/fYfMQkWHm8GM+EFYh1Yb3QnLagZRyP6bFQoHboj/A38dxHgFzZORx5LpKazDf Ye2ZIGTfQKnQafRB0cWVNv9u8YY0IZCQ0d+KDEDQMrcCv9/lC7G3AtYGbvLfUGzmMf/C14Y0ay9s N+Qyc8UVoY+A/xVQ0OHWAdLgJPDNpJQh2rH/kRKVRNcltxHXhXPU2DZAIJ+UcCaAa+ELgUBgYmzH IPxva9NRu5Frw02hu6BqtZ/QMdvNzMuQEM8hZWbyoP8ZcJI2PVRrw8Mgy9Bucbwv/3JhysHJ0iY0 hjTWBnLhqZH/2nPd/3XDa+HP59/ykRI+UT8/8db3T0DcYD8RC7FXT/xOJ+7R58Ah0PngFWHpcf8L wNYg1ZLkMaIyMXGSokJwfyOgk0El4T3APqDzoszLTP0LoGtA4kJxzrFvoZJTQdO/j4DAgMdxdKJ2 MZhqPflvH/p/+2yLlIWePrB0cDq8Ly9RcJ2QlIClky63kfovi5RbxgDO4kDiu8RNod8mIHkQyjCg UEEgaVvwasHccHC2cBTwfxVbkBDrEevHoyGQcMeDJyUhxtDVEP8CNgSPd4k6xUqfH98g7yH//zr/ SmEa7xhq+28PbxBtHmX/nRgeZf3f/uQeZf+vAL8Bx18UZgLPA9k7XR5lPMpAaZZwqka14CqgkGtt rOCdypFfMcC6AFYRYX0HJgR9AB3wAB4AQhABAAAAMwAAADxFUEVBSU5EREZPTktJQ01ITENBRUVF QUtDTUFBLmttYWxtQGVhcnRobGluay5uZXQ+AAALAAGACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAADhQAA AAAAAAMAA4AIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAABCFAAAAAAAAAwAHgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYA AAAAUoUAACdqAQAeAAmACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAABUhQAAAQAAAAQAAAA5LjAAHgAKgAgg BgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAANoUAAAEAAAABAAAAAAAAAB4AC4AIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAA ADeFAAABAAAAAQAAAAAAAAAeAAyACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAA4hQAAAQAAAAEAAAAAAAAA CwANgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAgoUAAAEAAAALADqACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAAO hQAAAAAAAAMAPIAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAABGFAAAAAAAAAwA9gAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAA AEYAAAAAGIUAAAAAAAALAFKACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAAGhQAAAAAAAAMAU4AIIAYAAAAA AMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAAGFAAAAAAAAAgH4DwEAAAAQAAAA2IJAdOwX8ke6o3RVn8q6fAIB+g8BAAAA EAAAANiCQHTsF/JHuqN0VZ/KunwCAfsPAQAAAJ8AAAAAAAAAOKG7EAXlEBqhuwgAKypWwgAAUFNU UFJYLkRMTAAAAAAAAAAATklUQfm/uAEAqgA32W4AAABDOlxEb2N1bWVudHMgYW5kIFNldHRpbmdz XEFkbWluaXN0cmF0b3JcTG9jYWwgU2V0dGluZ3NcQXBwbGljYXRpb24gRGF0YVxNaWNyb3NvZnRc T3V0bG9va1xvdXRsb29rLnBzdAAAAwD+DwUAAAADAA00/TcAAAIBfwABAAAANAAAADxQQ0VITEtL REtNTkhOUExPRkdHTE1FRExDRkFBLnJvZ2VydGFAdmlkZW90cm9uLmNhPgADAAYQ1zTtEAMABxAD DQAAAwAQEAAAAAADABEQAQAAAB4ACBABAAAAZQAAAEhJS0FUSEVSSU5FLFRIQU5LU0ZPUlRIRUlO Rk9USElTU0VFTVNUT0lNUExZVEhBVFRIRU1BUktFVFRFU1RFUklTRE9JTkdUSEVSSUdIVFRISU5H PT09PT09PT09PT09PT09PT0AAAAASk0= - --Boundary_(ID_EvbxkvU4Cg+ItJWPakaZcA)-- - - - -To subscribe/unsubscribe, email "majordomo@xmission.com" - -In the email body, write "subscribe canslim" or - -"unsubscribe canslim". Do not use quotes in your email.
Next Article (by Subject): RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Previous Article (by Subject): Re: [CANSLIM] market bottom "Gene Ricci"
Next in Thread: RE: [CANSLIM] market bottom Roger Tawa
Articles sorted by: [Date]
[Author]
[Subject]