CursedYear: 2005 Director: Wes Craven Written by: Kevin Williamson Threat: Werewolf Weapon of Choice: Silver Based upon: original |
Other movies in this series:
None
Rish's Reviews
There aren't enough werewolf movies out there. Maybe they're too expensive, since
psycho masks and vampire teeth run cheap. Maybe they're just hard to do right. I had
heard such awful things about this film, it was postponed several months, and Miramax
dumped it at a bad release time with almost no publicity, so it had to be bad. Still, I felt
I owed it to my heroes, Wes Craven and Kevin Williamson, to at least give the movie a
shot. And then I read up on the film--that after disastrous test screenings, they reshot
a great deal of the picture, then hacked it up to get a PG-13 rating. And again, I passed.
Tonight, though, with nothing productive to do, I went for a drive, and decided to catch
the flick at a cheap(ish) second-run theatre. And hey, it wasn't nearly as bad as I'd been
led to believe.
It wasn't great. No classic, like Scream
or Scream 2 (or even Scream
3, a movie I've grown to hate in recent years). But there are some good moments,
and at least one really good one.
And some lame ones too, particularly the ending.
Christina Ricci and Jesse Eisenberg play well-off orphans living in Los Angeles who run afoul of a
lycanthrope in the Hollywood hills, becoming infected by the werewolf curse. While
juggling the usual issues of the day (work, school, difficult relationships, homophobic
bullies who secretly are gay, struggles for acceptance, feeding the dog, front doors that
won't stay closed, etc.), they struggle with new questions: Who infected them? Who
else is infected? What is in store for them? And can it all be stopped?
The cast was really interesting. I've got two words for you: BAIO. Christina Ricci is
fairly good, though still tiny, cherubic, and bug-eyed. Not that I wouldn't make out with
her, but . . . Jesse Eisenberg certainly looked the part of the nerdy teen brother, though
the fact that I never related to (or sympathised with) his character must mean something
negative. Not sure what, though. Joshua Jackson, Portia de Rossi, Michael Rosenbaum,
and Judy Greer, all have shown up in better flicks. Is Shannon Elizabeth a Former Celebrity
yet? How about Craig Kilborn? Oh, and let's not forget R&B sensation Mya. While
not a rapper, I still frowned on her casting, but she was actually pretty good.
The werewolf, created apparently, by Rick Baker and KNB Effects, looks GREAT when
it's an anamatronic or puppet, looks pretty good when it's a guy in a suit, and looks lame
as hell when it's computer-generated. Look folks, if you can't afford ILM, don't do CGI.
I was entertained to see visual homages to both A
Nightmare on Elm Street and Scream, as well as more old time fare
like Frankenstein,
The Wolf Man,
Nosferatu, "Bonanza"
(not quite the Horror icon as the other ones), and The
Creature From the Black Lagoon. A dance club the size of a city block decked
out as a museum of horrors (and Cher) was an awesome setpiece, making me wish a
place like that actually existed. Not that I'd get in, mind you. But my sisters could tell
me all about it.
This was the first film in forty years (that I can think of) to use the old pentangle/Mark
of the Beast on the palms gag . . . probably because it's just stupid. They might as well
tried the widow's peak angle. The disbelief in werewolves everybody exhibits is pretty
entertaining, as is some of the dialogue, but it didn't have the inspired, polished feel of
Craven and Williamson's previous two collaborations. Several moments felt like Scream,
and the music by Marco Beltrami evoked it as well, but I kept thinking this was trying
to emulate it, unsuccessfully, like several flicks did in the late Nineties.
There were several subplots to sort through, but most of the interesting ones were probably
covered in the Ginger Snaps flicks (what are there, eight of those now?). The
social statement about gay-bashing was only mildly successful, as was the whodunnit
aspect of the script (since there were only three possible werewolf suspects, you could
pretty much pick any of them and you'd be right). A couple of the attempts at humor
fall incredibly flat, and do so at the detriment of the horror. It felt like a lot of it was a
vanity piece for Williamson, who has made so much money for Miramax (don't forget
Mrs. Tingle, The Faculty
and Halloween: 20 Years Later
as well), but I wonder if a lot of the brilliance and zest were in that first draft of the script,
and lost when the suits tried to fix it. I understand the need for Wes and Kevin to get
back together; I'm sure they had a lot of fun. I wish them better luck with their next
projects.
Best Scare: While not necessarily a scare, the best sequence of the film involved a
weredog.
I'd Recommend It To: Fans with low expectations.
Note: I just found out that Canada got the the original R-rated version, while America
got a watered-down PG-13 cut. Strike two.
Posted: April 5, 2005
Total Skulls: 15
Sequel | ||
Sequel setup | ||
Rips off earlier film | ||
Horror film showing on TV/in theater in movie | ||
Future celebrity appears | ||
Former celebrity appears | Scott Baio | |
Bad title | ||
Bad premise | ||
Bad acting | ||
Bad dialogue | ||
Bad execution | ||
MTV Editing | ||
OTS | ||
Girl unnecessarily gets naked | ||
Wanton sex | ||
Death associated with sex | ||
Unfulfilled promise of nudity | ||
Characters forget about threat | ||
Secluded location | ||
Power is cut | ||
Phone lines are cut | ||
Someone investigates a strange noise | ||
Someone runs up stairs instead of going out front door | ||
Camera is the killer | ||
Victims cower in front of a window/door | ||
Victim locks self in with killer | ||
Victim running from killer inexplicably falls | ||
Toilet stall scene | ||
Shower/bath scene | ||
Car stalls or won't start | ||
Cat jumps out | ||
Fake scare | ||
Laughable scare | ||
Stupid discovery of corpse | ||
Dream sequence | ||
Hallucination/Vision | ||
No one believes only witness | ||
Crazy, drunk, old man knows the truth | ||
Warning goes unheeded | ||
Music detracts from scene | ||
Death in first five minutes | ||
x years before/later | ||
Flashback sequence | ||
Dark and stormy night | ||
Killer doesn't stay dead | ||
Killer wears a mask | ||
Killer is in closet | ||
Killer is in car with victim | ||
Villain is more sympathetic than heroes | ||
Unscary villain/monster | ||
Beheading | ||
Blood fountain | ||
Blood spatters - camera, wall, etc. | ||
Poor death effect | ||
Excessive gore | ||
No one dies at all | ||
Virgin survives | ||
Geek/Nerd survives | ||
Little kid lamely survives | ||
Dog/Pet miraculously survives | ||
Unresolved subplots | ||
"It was all a dream" ending | ||
Unbelievably happy ending | ||
Unbelievably crappy ending | ||
What the hell? |